Form 5471 and a UK Brewery or Pub Company
By US-UK Tax Advisors cross-border tax team · Last updated NOV 01, 2026

A UK pub company with freeholds and a brewing plant produces US numbers far from its UK accounts. Here is how we prepare the return, schedule by schedule, now.
Key Takeaways
- Covers cross-border tax for US-UK cross-border taxpayers
- Applies to US persons with UK ties and UK residents with US income
- Highlights the filing, reporting and tax-treaty points to check
- Get personalised advice before acting on your own facts
Form 5471 is required from a US citizen or resident who controls a UK brewery or pub company, and for a sole owner it means the full return with every separate schedule, whether or not the company paid a dividend. The UK accounts are only the starting point. A business built on freehold pubs and brewing plant has to be rebuilt on US depreciation rules, its income has to be sorted into trading and rental streams, and since the 2025 Act its tangible assets no longer shelter any of the US inclusion for tax years beginning after 31 December 2025.
A pub group can have managed houses, tenanted houses, a brewery selling to its own pubs and the free trade, a flat over the bar, and a director's loan that moves monthly. In the returns we prepare, the difficulty is rarely the form. It is that the UK accounts, the UK tax computation and the US computation disagree in ways that shift each year.
Who must file Form 5471 for a UK pub company, and in which category?
Filing depends on ownership and office, not on profit, dividends or where the owner lives. The Instructions for Form 5471 (revision 12/2025), at https://www.irs.gov/instructions/i5471, set out five categories. These are the ones that matter for a UK Ltd holding pubs and a brewery:
- Category 2: a US citizen or resident who is an officer or director of a foreign corporation in which a US person acquired a 10 percent stake, or a further 10 percent. A US-citizen director brought in during a refinancing can be caught this way without holding a single share.
- Category 3: a US person who acquires stock reaching the 10 percent threshold, becomes a US person while holding it, or sells down below it. Buying into a pub group, or moving to the United States while owning one, is a Category 3 event for that year.
- Category 4: a US person with control of the company during its annual accounting period, meaning more than 50 percent of voting power or value.
- Category 5a: a US shareholder who owned stock in a controlled foreign corporation during its tax year and on the last day it was a CFC.
The typical owner-operator meets both Category 4 and Category 5a. Such a filer checks only Category 4. That box does not reduce the work: the instructions say a sole owner of a CFC described in both categories completes all six pages of the form and separate Schedules E, G-1, H, H-1, I-1, J, M, P, Q and R. Two points follow. First, the 30-day rule for CFC status was removed by the 2017 Act, so a short period of ownership can still count. Second, a 50-50 company needs care, because control requires more than 50 percent. If the other half belongs to a non-US spouse or business partner, we work through the attribution rules before deciding whether the company is a CFC at all, because the answer changes which schedules are due and whether there is any US inclusion.
The penalty is the reason this gets attention. The instructions give $10,000 per annual accounting period per foreign corporation for a failure under section 6038(a), which covers Form 5471 and Schedule M, plus a further $10,000 for each 30-day period once 90 days have passed after an IRS notice, capped at $50,000. Creditable foreign taxes can also be reduced. A group of three UK companies has three separate exposures.
Why do Form 5471 numbers differ so much from UK pub company accounts?
Because the UK figures answer different questions. UK accounts follow accounting standards, the UK tax computation replaces accounts depreciation with capital allowances, and the US computation replaces both with its own depreciation system. Earnings and profits, or E&P, is the US measure of a foreign corporation's economic earnings, which decides how distributions are characterised. Schedule H of Form 5471 reconciles current-year accounts profit to current E&P, and Schedule J carries the accumulated balance from year to year in the company's functional currency, split between previously taxed and untaxed pools.
The adjustments that recur on pub and brewery returns are these:
- Accounts depreciation on freeholds and plant is removed and replaced with US depreciation.
- Capital allowances play no part in the US figures. They affect the US return only through the amount of UK tax paid.
- Revaluation of freehold pubs and impairment of a struggling site can move the UK balance sheet substantially. We do not treat an unrealised uplift as earnings, and we track US basis separately on a site-by-site register.
- Deferred tax in the accounts is not a current foreign tax. It does not reach Schedule E, which deals with foreign income taxes.
How does US depreciation apply to UK freehold pubs and brewing plant?
The alternative depreciation system, or ADS, is the mandatory US method for tangible property used predominantly outside the United States. Section 168(g)(1)(A), at https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/168, makes it compulsory rather than elective, so a UK pub is not eligible for the shorter recovery periods a US building or machine would get. The same subsection sets the recovery periods: 40 years for nonresidential real property, 30 years for residential rental property, the class life for property that has one, and 12 years for personal property with no class life. Property required to use ADS also falls outside US bonus depreciation.
For a pub company, the practical work is allocation. When a freehold is bought for a single price, the US computation needs that price divided between land, which is not depreciated, the building, and fixtures such as cellar cooling, kitchen equipment and bar fittings. Brewing vessels, fermenters, conditioning tanks and packaging lines each need a class-life determination; we do not assume one figure across a plant. We build this once as a fixed asset register in sterling, then roll it forward. If earlier returns simply copied accounts depreciation, moving onto the right basis may be an accounting method change, not a simple correction on the next return.
How do UK capital allowances differ for a brewery or pub?
They can be far faster for plant and far slower or unavailable for the property itself. GOV.UK states the Annual Investment Allowance is £1 million for limited companies and applies to most plant and machinery (https://www.gov.uk/capital-allowances/annual-investment-allowance), so a new brewhouse may be written off for UK tax in a single year. The Structures and Buildings Allowance runs at 3 percent a year from 1 April 2020 over a period of 33 and one third years, but it excludes land and costs for any residence (https://www.gov.uk/guidance/claiming-capital-allowances-for-structures-and-buildings). A flat above a pub therefore has to be separated from the trading areas, and whether a purchased older building carries any allowance at all depends on the history of its construction spending.
The US side has no equivalent single-year write-off for a CFC's plant. That would be a harmless timing difference if the two systems ran independently, but UK tax paid is the raw material for the US high-tax analysis and the foreign tax credit. This is where a capital-heavy business differs from other UK companies.
What happened to GILTI and QBAI for asset-heavy UK companies?
The regime formerly called GILTI is now net CFC tested income, and the tangible-asset return has gone. Section 951A, at https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/951A, now requires each US shareholder to include net CFC tested income, being the excess of the shareholder's pro rata share of tested income over its share of tested losses across all its CFCs. Public Law 119-21 of 4 July 2025 struck the provisions on net deemed tangible income return and qualified business asset investment, with these amendments applying to taxable years beginning after 31 December 2025.
For an owner with millions of pounds of freehold pubs and brewing plant, this is a substantial change. Qualified business asset investment, or QBAI, used to reduce the inclusion by a return on depreciable tangible assets, and a pub group often had plenty. Schedule I-1 in the 12/2025 instructions still carries QBAI and specified tangible property headings, and they remain relevant to earlier years. For years inside the new rules, the ADS asset register no longer earns any exclusion, although it still drives depreciation in tested income and E&P.
Tested income is a CFC's gross income, with listed exclusions such as Subpart F income and dividends from related persons, less the deductions, including taxes, properly allocable to it. Schedule I-1 is where we compute that at corporation level. An individual owner sits differently from a US corporate shareholder, so we model a section 962 election where it may reduce the US charge. The 2025 Act also altered the deduction and credit percentages, and we take them from current law for the year being filed. The instructions also refer to Notice 2025-75 on a pro rata share transition rule, which matters when an owner buys or sells part of a company during a year.
Are pub rents foreign personal holding company income?
They are unless an exception applies. Foreign personal holding company income, or FPHCI, starts with dividends, interest, royalties, rents and annuities under section 954(c)(1)(A), at https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/954, and it is a category of Subpart F income taxed directly to the US shareholder. Section 954(c)(2)(A) removes rents derived in the active conduct of a trade or business and received from a person other than a related person. Both limbs must be met, so rent from the owner's own operating company does not qualify under this exception.
The regulations at https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.954-2 give the tests. For real property, rents qualify where the lessor, through its own officers or staff, regularly performs active and substantial management and operational functions while the property is leased. A separate route covers property leased through a marketing organisation the lessor maintains and operates in a foreign country, regularly engaged in marketing or marketing and servicing the property and substantial relative to the rents. That organisation is treated as substantial if active leasing expenses equal or exceed 25 percent of adjusted leasing profit. Payments to outside agents and contractors get specific treatment in that calculation, so we run it from the regulation itself rather than from the management accounts.
What this means on the ground depends on the pub model. In a managed house, the company employs the manager and staff and sells food and drink. That is trading income, and it goes to tested income, not rent. In a tenanted house, a publican trades on their own account and pays the company rent. Our reading is that a full repairing lease run from a spreadsheet with an outside surveyor would struggle to meet the staff test, while a company with its own area managers, repairs team and lettings staff has a real argument. That argument has to be evidenced by who actually does the work. Employing people somewhere in the group is not sufficient, because the test looks at the lessor.
The tied lease is the subject we find covered least. Where a tenant must buy beer from the company, the receipts are two income streams: sales of goods, usually at a price above the free-trade rate, and dry rent, often set below the open-market rate as a result. The contract splits them on its face, and we follow it, while checking it reflects the commercial position. Each stream goes to a different place: the beer sale is generally trading income, and the dry rent goes through the rents analysis. Machine income and any share of takings need similar reading. One combined turnover line misstates the Subpart F figure.
Group structure adds a further layer. A property company leasing to a sister operating company is receiving rent from a related person, so the active exception is unavailable. Section 954(c)(3) contains a separate rule for certain related-party rents for the use of property in the CFC's own country of organisation, which we test for UK property leased within a UK group. Each corporation is reported separately.
When can rents or other income escape Subpart F?
Three further statutory rules can change the result, and all three are in section 954(b). The de minimis rule treats none of the income as foreign base company income if that income, with any gross insurance income, is less than the lesser of 5 percent of gross income or $1,000,000. The full-inclusion rule works the other way: above 70 percent, all of the company's gross income is treated as such income, which can matter for a pure tenanted company. The high-tax exception applies where the taxpayer shows the income bore an effective foreign rate greater than 90 percent of the maximum rate under section 11.
Gains also need attention. Selling a tenanted pub may produce FPHCI gain, because section 954(c) reaches gains on certain property that gives rise to rents. Selling a managed house used in the trade will usually be analysed differently. So the classification of a site in the years before a disposal can decide how the gain is taxed in the United States, and the gain itself is computed on the US basis, which will differ from the UK figure.
Worked illustration: the year a UK brewery buys new plant
Every figure here is our own illustration, not a client's, and is simplified. Assume a US citizen owns all of a UK Ltd. It holds freehold buildings with a US-allocated cost of £1,200,000 (land excluded) and buys brewing plant for £400,000 in Year 1. Profit before tax in the accounts is £480,000 in both Year 1 and Year 2, after accounts depreciation of £52,000. Gross income after cost of sales is £1,800,000, of which £70,000 is dry rent from tenanted pubs. We assume a UK tax rate of 25 percent purely for the arithmetic, an exchange rate of US$1.30 to £1, a 12-year ADS period for the plant, which would have to be confirmed against its class life, and we ignore first-year conventions and any Structures and Buildings Allowance.
- UK tax, Year 1: £480,000 plus £52,000 added back, less £400,000 Annual Investment Allowance, gives taxable profit of £132,000 and UK tax of £33,000.
- UK tax, Year 2: no new plant and no further allowance on the plant already written off, so taxable profit is £532,000 and UK tax is £133,000.
- US depreciation, both years: £30,000 on the building (£1,200,000 over 40 years) plus £33,333 on the plant (£400,000 over 12 years), a total of £63,333. That is £11,333 more than the accounts charge.
- US pre-tax income, both years: £480,000 less £11,333 gives £468,667.
- Effective UK rate on the US base: £33,000 over £468,667 is about 7.0 percent in Year 1; £133,000 over £468,667 is about 28.4 percent in Year 2.
- After-tax US income: £435,667 in Year 1, about US$566,367 at the assumed rate; £335,667 in Year 2, about US$436,367.
- Rents and de minimis: 5 percent of £1,800,000 is £90,000, and that is below $1,000,000 at the assumed rate, so the £70,000 of rent is under the threshold. If two more pubs moved from managed to tenanted, it could cross it.
The UK allowance only moves tax between years, but the US position does not even out the same way. Year 1 has low UK tax against a full US base, so the high-tax route is out of reach and any US charge depends on the credit position. Year 2 has heavy UK tax against the same base. Foreign tax credit limits work year by year, so excess tax in one year does not simply repair a shortfall in another. We therefore model a large plant purchase across both years before the first return is filed. Under the old regime, a QBAI return on these assets would also have reduced the inclusion. Under current law it does not.
Are UK alcohol duty and VAT foreign taxes on Form 5471?
No. Schedule E covers foreign income taxes for which a credit is allowed, along with deemed-paid amounts and disallowed taxes. Alcohol duty is a charge on the product, not on net income, so we treat it as a cost in computing income and not as a credit item. A pub buying duty-paid stock bears it within the purchase price. VAT collected on sales and reclaimed on inputs generally passes through the company, so turnover and costs need to be stated net of recoverable VAT, and irrecoverable VAT follows the cost it relates to. Duty is a large number in a brewery's accounts, so we check that income on Schedule C is not inflated by duty shown on a separate line.
How do director's loans and related-party dealings show up on Schedule M?
Schedule M reports transactions between the CFC and its shareholders and other related persons, and the instructions address accrued payments and receipts as well as cash. In a pub group, that usually includes a director's loan account, rent paid to an owner who holds a freehold personally, management charges between sister companies, intercompany beer sales, and salary or dividends to the owner. Loan lines look at the balance during the year, not simply the closing figure, so a director's account that is cleared by a dividend at the year end can still need reporting.
A loan from the company to its US owner is also not just a reporting item. It can be an investment in US property under section 956, which can produce a separate inclusion, while on the UK side an overdrawn loan by a participator in a close company can bring its own corporation tax charge. A loan the other way, from owner to company to fund a refurbishment, also belongs on Schedule M, and any interest goes on the owner's return. We reconcile the director's loan ledger month by month to prepare this schedule.
Our preparation checklist for a pub or brewery Form 5471
We built this decision sequence from the returns we prepare. It is the order in which we ask the questions, because each answer changes the next:
- If the owner holds more than 50 percent by vote or value, then treat as Category 4, check only that box where Category 5a is also met, and plan for the full set of schedules for each company.
- If ownership is exactly 50-50, then test attribution before assuming control or CFC status.
- If the group has more than one UK company, then prepare one Form 5471 per corporation and map every intercompany flow first.
- If freeholds were bought for one price, then allocate between land, building and fixtures and open a sterling ADS register by site.
- If a pub has living accommodation, then separate it for both the UK allowance claim and the US property classification.
- If a pub is tenanted, then split dry rent from beer sales, and test the rent against the active-conduct rules and the related-person limb.
- If significant plant was bought, then model UK tax and the US position for that year and the next before filing.
- If the director's loan moved during the year, then rebuild monthly balances for Schedule M and review section 956.
- If earlier returns copied UK accounts, then assess whether a method change or amended filings are needed.
What if Form 5471 was never filed for the pub company?
This is common among US citizens who have lived in the UK for decades and whose UK accountant never raised it. Form 5471 is due with the owner's income tax return, including extensions. Where the failure was non-willful, the Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures are often the route: the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures carry no penalty for those who qualify, while the 5 percent miscellaneous offshore penalty belongs to the Streamlined Domestic Offshore Procedures only. In the catch-up filings we prepare, reconstructing the asset register takes longest. Signature authority over company bank accounts can also create a late FBAR, filed through FinCEN's BSA E-Filing System with a reason for lateness, or inside the Streamlined package.
An owner with a brewery and freehold pubs is a capital-heavy taxpayer in a regime that stopped rewarding capital in 2026. The task is to get the asset base right once, sort income by what each pub actually does, and test each year on its own numbers.
Related reading and tools
- US Tax Services & IRS Compliance
- UK Tax Services
- IRS Streamlined Filing
- UK Income Tax Calculator
- US Federal Income Tax Calculator
Every situation is different. Book a cross-border tax consultation to discuss how these rules apply to you.
Authoritative sources
IRS — Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures
FinCEN — Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR)
GOV.UK — Tax on foreign income
IRS — Foreign Earned Income Exclusion



