Missed US Tax Returns for US Insurance Executives in London
By US-UK Tax Advisors cross-border tax team · Last updated OCT 26, 2026

US insurance executives in London often miss US returns despite UK PAYE. How we catch up: Streamlined filing, bonus and share award sourcing, FBARs and 8938.
Key Takeaways
- Covers cross-border tax for US-UK cross-border taxpayers
- Applies to US persons with UK ties and UK residents with US income
- Highlights the filing, reporting and tax-treaty points to check
- Get personalised advice before acting on your own facts
Missed US tax returns are a common and fixable problem for American executives, underwriters and brokers working in the London insurance and reinsurance market: UK PAYE does not satisfy your US filing obligation, but for most non-willful filers the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures let you catch up with three years of returns and six years of FBARs and no penalty. The real work is not the forms. It is getting the sourcing of bonuses and deferred share awards right across several years, choosing between the foreign earned income exclusion and the foreign tax credit, and reporting UK accounts and share plan holdings correctly.
In the returns we prepare for senior insurance professionals in London, the pattern is consistent: an individual paid entirely through UK payroll, paying substantial UK tax, assumed that settled the matter. Years later there are several unfiled years, bonus statements, deferred share awards vesting across several tax years and a UK workplace pension. This guide sets out how we approach that catch-up and where the numbers usually go wrong.
Do I still have to file US tax returns if I pay UK tax through PAYE?
Yes. The United States taxes its citizens on worldwide income regardless of where they live. IRS Publication 54, the Tax Guide for U.S. Citizens and Resident Aliens Abroad, at https://www.irs.gov/publications/p54, states that worldwide income is generally subject to US income tax regardless of where you are living, and that citizens abroad are subject to the same filing requirements as those living in the United States. Paying UK tax at source, even at the highest UK rates, does not remove the requirement to file Form 1040. What UK tax does is give you the raw material for relief on the US return, usually through foreign tax credits, so that the same income is not taxed twice in full.
A missed US tax return is a required US return that was not filed by its due date. For an insurance executive on a senior London salary the filing threshold is always met, so the question is only how much US tax the return shows after relief and which reporting forms should have accompanied it.
Missed US tax returns: which catch-up route fits a London insurance executive?
There are two broad routes. The first is the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures, often shortened to SFOP. The second is simply filing the delinquent returns late outside any programme and dealing with whatever penalties the IRS assesses. For a non-willful filer living in London, SFOP is almost always the better route, and the reasons are set out on the IRS page at https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/us-taxpayers-residing-outside-the-united-states for non-willful filers living abroad.
Under SFOP you file the most recent three years of US tax returns for which the due date has passed and the most recent six years of FBARs for which the FBAR due date has passed. You sign Form 14653, a certification that your failure to file was non-willful, meaning it resulted from negligence, inadvertence, mistake or a good-faith misunderstanding of the law. You pay the full tax and interest shown on the returns. In return, the IRS page confirms that compliant filers are not subject to failure-to-file and failure-to-pay penalties, accuracy-related penalties, information return penalties or FBAR penalties. The Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures carry no penalty at all. The 5% miscellaneous offshore penalty that people sometimes mention belongs to the separate Streamlined Domestic Offshore Procedures for US residents, not to the foreign version.
Eligibility for a US citizen turns on a non-residency test. In any one or more of the most recent three years for which the return due date has passed, you must have had no US abode and been physically outside the United States for at least 330 full days. Many insurance executives travel to the US for renewals, client meetings and conferences. Heavy travel in one year does not disqualify you if another of the three years meets the 330-day test, but the abode element still needs care if you kept a US home available to you. You must also not already be under IRS examination for the relevant years.
The IRS page sets out the mechanics we follow on every SFOP filing:
- File Form 1040 for years where no return was filed, or Form 1040X where a return was filed but was incomplete, with all required information returns attached.
- Write Streamlined Foreign Offshore in red at the top of the first page of each return and information return.
- Attach a copy of the signed Form 14653 to each return, and send the original signed certification with the package.
- Mail the returns on paper to the dedicated Austin address given on the IRS page; electronic filing is not accepted for these submissions.
- File the six delinquent FBARs electronically through FinCEN's BSA E-Filing System, selecting Other as the reason for late filing and entering Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures in the explanation box.
- Pay all tax and interest due with the submission.
Note what is not on that list. The IRS withdrew its separate Delinquent FBAR Submission Procedures page around July 2026, so that is no longer a live, named route. Late FBARs are filed through the BSA E-Filing System with a late-filing reason, or inside the Streamlined procedures as described above.
What happens if I file late without using the Streamlined procedures?
Filing delinquent returns outside SFOP is possible, but it gives up the penalty protection. The IRS failure-to-file penalty, explained at https://www.irs.gov/payments/failure-to-file-penalty, is 5% of the unpaid tax for each month or part of a month a return is late, up to a maximum of 25%. For returns more than 60 days late there is a minimum penalty equal to the lesser of a fixed dollar amount or 100% of the tax required to be shown; the IRS lists the fixed amount as $525 for returns due after 31 December 2025, $510 for returns due in 2025 and $485 for returns due in 2024. Because the penalty is computed on unpaid tax, a year in which foreign tax credits eliminate all US tax produces little or no failure-to-file penalty.
Why use SFOP if UK tax wipes out the US liability? Because missing Forms 8938 and FBARs carry their own penalties that are not computed on tax due, and SFOP removes those too for non-willful filers. In the returns we prepare, the deciding factor is rarely the income tax; it is the information reporting.
Should a high earner use the foreign earned income exclusion or the foreign tax credit?
The foreign earned income exclusion, claimed on Form 2555, lets a qualifying individual exclude a capped amount of foreign earned income from US tax. The IRS page at https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/foreign-earned-income-exclusion lists the maximum exclusion for 2023 as $120,000, and the IRS inflation adjustment announcement at https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-releases-tax-inflation-adjustments-for-tax-year-2025 confirms $126,500 for 2024 and $130,000 for 2025. To qualify you must have a tax home abroad and meet either the bona fide residence test or the physical presence test of at least 330 full days in a foreign country during any 12 consecutive months.
For a senior insurance professional, those caps cover only a fraction of salary and cash bonus. The foreign tax credit, claimed on Form 1116, works differently: it credits UK income tax actually paid against the US tax on the same foreign-source income. Because UK tax on income at this level is typically higher than the US federal tax on the same wages, the credit frequently reduces US tax on UK-source employment income to nil and can generate excess credits. In the returns we prepare for this group, the foreign tax credit alone is the usual starting point, with the exclusion used only where it produces a better answer over the full set of years.
Several rules shape that choice:
- No double benefit. Publication 54 explains that you cannot claim a credit for foreign taxes allocable to income you exclude. If you exclude part of your wages, the UK tax on that excluded slice is lost for credit purposes.
- Stacking. Where the exclusion is claimed, tax on the remaining income is figured at the rates that would have applied without the exclusion, so excluding the first slice does not drag the rest into lower brackets.
- Revocation. The exclusion is an election. Publication 54 explains that once revoked, re-electing within five years requires IRS approval through a ruling request, which makes switching back and forth between methods costly.
- Late payments. The IRS exclusion page lists payments received after the end of the tax year following the year in which the work was done among the amounts that do not count as foreign earned income. Deferred awards that pay out two or more years after the work cannot be excluded at all.
- Housing. A separate housing exclusion or deduction can apply to qualifying London housing costs, within the same election framework.
The late-payment rule is decisive for insurance executives, because much senior pay in this market is deferred. Mixing the exclusion on salary with credits on deferred awards often fragments the UK tax pool and strands credits, so a pure foreign tax credit approach is usually cleaner.
How are bonuses and deferred share awards sourced across years and countries?
Sourcing is the question that decides how much foreign tax credit you can actually use. Only foreign-source income supports the credit, so any part of your pay that is treated as US-source income is exposed to US tax with limited UK credit against it. The rule for employees is in Treasury Regulation section 1.861-4, published at https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.861-4 for reference. Compensation for services performed partly inside and partly outside the United States is sourced on a time basis: the US portion bears the same relation to total compensation as US workdays bear to total workdays in the relevant period.
For ordinary salary the period is generally the calendar year. For compensation that relates to services over more than one year, the regulation sources it over the period to which the compensation is attributable. A cash bonus paid in March for the previous year's performance is sourced by reference to the workdays of the year it rewards, not the year it is paid. For equity-based awards, the regulation treats the relevant period for stock options as running generally from grant until the employment conditions for exercise are met, and the same multi-year logic is how we approach deferred share awards and long-term incentive awards that vest over several years.
In practice, a deferred share award granted in one year and vesting in tranches over the following three years is not one number. Each tranche has its own sourcing period, its own count of US workdays and non-US workdays, and its own exchange rate at vesting. If you spent part of that period working in the United States before the London move, or travelled heavily to US clients, a slice of each tranche is US-source income. That slice is where residual US tax most often appears on a catch-up filing.
Why do US workdays matter so much for London-based insurance executives?
Because the time-basis rule turns travel diaries into tax. Renewal seasons, client visits and industry events can add up to several weeks in the United States each year. Every US workday shifts part of salary, bonus and the relevant tranches of deferred awards from foreign source to US source. The UK may still tax that income as your country of residence, which is exactly where double taxation risk sits and why the treaty relief articles have to be worked through year by year.
The failure mode we see most often is a reconstruction based on a rough guess of travel. We rebuild the workday count from calendars, expense records and travel bookings for every year that touches a sourcing period, because the IRS page notes that Streamlined returns can still be selected for audit, and additional tax found on examination can attract penalties on that amount.
How do you map a multi-year bonus deferral across missed years?
This is the gap most catch-up guides skip. A London insurance executive with four or five unfiled years will typically have awards granted in years that are outside the three-year SFOP window but vesting in years that are inside it. The filing obligation attaches to the year the income is taxed in the United States, which for most share awards is the year of vesting, but the sourcing calculation reaches back to the grant year. So even though you only file three returns, you need the facts for the earlier years as well.
Our working method for each award is set out below:
- List every award letter, grant statement and vesting confirmation, including awards that were forfeited, since forfeitures affect what was taxed in each country.
- For each tranche, record the grant date, vesting date, number of shares delivered or sold to cover tax, market value at vesting and the UK tax and National Insurance withheld through payroll.
- Define the sourcing period for each tranche from grant to vesting, and count US and non-US workdays within it, crossing into years you are not filing.
- Convert the vesting value and the UK tax to US dollars using a consistent, documented exchange rate method.
- Allocate each tranche to the US tax year in which it is taxable and carry the US-source and foreign-source split into the Form 1116 computation for that year.
- Track the shares after vesting, because the vesting value becomes the base for any later gain or loss.
The UK tax year runs April to April while the US year follows the calendar, so one vesting event can fall in different UK and US years. Matching UK tax to the correct US year is what makes the foreign tax credit hold up.
Worked example: an underwriter in London with four unfiled years (illustration)
The following figures are an illustration only. They are rounded and simplified, and they assume an exchange rate of 1.30 US dollars to the pound throughout, purely for clarity. A real filing uses the actual rates and the actual documents.
Assume a US citizen underwriter moved to London several years ago, has not filed US returns for the last four years, and has had no contact from the IRS. In each of the last three filed-due years she spent between 20 and 30 working days in the United States and was otherwise based in London, with no US home. Her UK salary is 400,000 pounds, roughly 520,000 dollars, and she receives a cash bonus of around 200,000 pounds each year, paid in the following spring. Each year she is also granted a deferred share award worth about 150,000 pounds, vesting in three equal tranches over the following three years.
Eligibility comes first. She was outside the United States for well over 330 full days in at least one of the three most recent years and had no US abode, so she meets the SFOP non-residency test. Her failure to file was a good-faith misunderstanding that UK PAYE covered everything, which supports a non-willful certification on Form 14653. She files the three most recent years of returns and six years of FBARs.
On method, her salary alone is several times the 2024 exclusion cap of 126,500 dollars, and her deferred tranches pay out more than a year after the services, so they could not be excluded in any case. We prepare her returns using the foreign tax credit only. Her UK tax on salary and bonus comfortably exceeds the US tax on the foreign-source portion, so the US tax on that portion is reduced to nil and excess credits arise.
On sourcing, suppose one year she had 25 US workdays out of 230, about 11%, so roughly 57,000 dollars of that year's salary is US-source. The following spring's bonus is sourced on the workdays of the year it rewards, and each vesting tranche across its own grant-to-vest period, so US workdays in years outside the filing window still affect tranches vesting inside it. In this illustration the US-source slices exceed 100,000 dollars a year.
That US-source income is where any residual US tax lands, and whether it is fully relieved depends on how the treaty's relief articles and resourcing rules apply to her facts in each year. The returns show a modest US balance in two of the three years, which she pays with interest when she submits. Because she uses SFOP, no failure-to-file, information return or FBAR penalties apply. Had she instead filed late outside the programme, the failure-to-file penalty would have been computed on those unpaid balances, and her unfiled Forms 8938 and FBARs would have remained exposed.
How is a UK workplace pension treated on missed US returns?
A UK workplace pension raises two separate questions. The first is whether employer contributions and the growth inside the plan are taxable in the United States year by year. Under US domestic law, a non-US pension plan does not automatically receive the deferral that a US qualified plan receives. The US-UK income tax treaty contains a pensions article, Article 18, which can give relief for contributions to, and accruals within, a pension scheme established in the other country, subject to conditions about the scheme, the individual and the level of contributions. Whether that relief applies, and to what extent, depends on the specific facts, and claiming a treaty position can require disclosure on the return.
The second question is reporting. A UK pension may need to be considered for Form 8938 and the FBAR, depending on how the arrangement is structured and what interest you hold. We review each arrangement individually, and settle the position in the first SFOP year because it sets the template for every year after.
Which UK accounts and share plan holdings go on the FBAR and Form 8938?
The FBAR, FinCEN Form 114, is required where the aggregate value of your foreign financial accounts exceeds 10,000 dollars at any time during the calendar year. The IRS comparison at https://www.irs.gov/businesses/comparison-of-form-8938-and-fbar-requirements confirms that balances across accounts are combined for that test, that the FBAR is filed electronically through FinCEN's BSA E-Filing System rather than with the tax return, and that it is due 15 April with an automatic extension to 15 October. For a London executive, the current account that receives salary will usually cross that threshold within a single pay cycle, so FBAR filing is essentially certain.
Form 8938 is filed with the tax return. The same IRS comparison gives the thresholds for taxpayers living abroad: for single filers and those married filing separately, more than 200,000 dollars on the last day of the year or more than 300,000 dollars at any time during it; for married couples filing jointly, more than 400,000 dollars on the last day or more than 600,000 dollars at any time. Executives with deferred share holdings and savings typically exceed those levels.
Share plan holdings need particular care. Vested shares held in a nominee account by a plan administrator may be a foreign financial account in which you have a financial interest, reportable on both forms; the IRS comparison notes that securities held inside a reportable account do not need to be listed separately. Shares held outside any account can be specified foreign financial assets for Form 8938 even where no FBAR is due. Unvested awards are generally a promise to deliver shares in future rather than an account balance, but we check the plan terms before treating them either way.
Do I owe state tax if I lived in a US state before moving to London?
Possibly, and it is easy to miss. State income tax is separate from federal tax, and the Streamlined procedures cover federal returns and FBARs only. If you moved to London from a state with an income tax, the state may continue to treat you as resident until you have clearly broken your connections there, and some states apply domicile tests that look at where you intend your permanent home to be, the property you keep, where your family lives and where your professional and social ties sit.
The issue is sharpest for executives who moved in the last two or three years, kept a home in the state, or still received income from a former US employer. Deferred awards granted while working in a state can carry a state-source component after you leave, so we review the departure year alongside the federal catch-up.
Related reading and tools
- US Tax Services & IRS Compliance
- UK Tax Services
- IRS Streamlined Filing
- UK Income Tax Calculator
- US Federal Income Tax Calculator
Every situation is different. Book a cross-border tax consultation to discuss how these rules apply to you.
Authoritative sources
IRS — Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures
FinCEN — Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR)
GOV.UK — Tax on foreign income
IRS — Foreign Earned Income Exclusion



