Missed US Tax Returns for UK Garden Centre Owners
By US-UK Tax Advisors cross-border tax team · Last updated NOV 13, 2026

A US citizen running a UK garden centre can usually fix years of unfiled US returns. Here is how the company, the freehold and Christmas trade map to IRS forms.
Key Takeaways
- Covers cross-border tax for US-UK cross-border taxpayers
- Applies to US persons with UK ties and UK residents with US income
- Highlights the filing, reporting and tax-treaty points to check
- Get personalised advice before acting on your own facts
Missed US tax returns are a common problem for American citizens who own a garden centre in the UK, and the usual fix is a structured catch-up filing rather than a crisis. If the lapse was non-willful and you live in the UK, the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures let you file three years of returns and six years of FBARs with no penalty. The harder part is the business: the company, the freehold site, the concession tenants and the Christmas peak all have to be translated into US forms that were never designed with a plant centre in mind.
The owners we see in this position are rarely careless. They file CT600s on time, reconcile VAT every quarter and know their margin on bedding plants to the penny. What slipped is the US side, usually because the UK accountant never handled American returns and nobody told the owner that a US passport brings a separate set of annual obligations.
Missed US tax returns: why is a garden centre a harder case than most?
A garden centre combines heavy property, mixed income and sharp seasonality inside one business. Each of those features creates its own US reporting item, so a missing personal return is rarely just a missing Form 1040. It usually means missing company information returns, missing FBARs for business bank accounts and a set of US computations nobody has ever prepared.
Think about what sits on a typical balance sheet. There is freehold land, a shop building, glasshouses or polytunnels, a car park, perhaps a cafe kitchen and a covered outdoor sales area. Income comes from plant and sundries sales, cafe takings, rent or licence fees from concession traders such as an aquatics unit or a farm shop, and a Christmas trade in trees, decorations and grotto tickets that can produce a large share of the year's profit in a few weeks. For US purposes every one of those lines has to be classified, measured on US principles and reported.
The other complication is ownership. Whether you hold all of the shares, a majority or a minority changes which category of Form 5471 you file and how much of the company's income reaches your own US return.
Which US forms does a UK garden centre owner actually need?
That depends on how the garden centre is held. A limited company brings Form 5471 every year, a partnership or LLP usually brings Form 8865, and a sole trade goes on Schedule C. In every case you also file Form 1040, an FBAR for accounts you own or can sign on, and often Form 8938.
- Limited company: Form 5471 attached to your Form 1040 each year, with the schedules your filer category requires, such as the income statement, balance sheet, earnings and profits and related-party transactions.
- Partnership or LLP: Form 8865, which the IRS describes at https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-form-8865 as the return a US person files to report information under sections 6038, 6038B and 6046A, covering controlled foreign partnerships, transfers to them and changes in interests.
- Sole trader: Schedule C for the trading profit, plus Schedule SE unless you hold evidence that UK National Insurance covers you under the US-UK social security agreement.
- FBAR (FinCEN Form 114): every non-US account in which you have a financial interest or over which you have signature authority, which for most owners includes the garden centre's own current, deposit and card-settlement accounts.
- Form 8938: specified foreign financial assets above the reporting thresholds for your filing status, which can include your shares in the garden centre company itself.
- Form 1116: the foreign tax credit claim that carries UK income tax paid on your salary and dividends across to the US return.
The FBAR point for business accounts surprises many owners. The IRS Internal Revenue Manual at https://www.irs.gov/irm/part4/irm_04-026-016 explains that signature authority attributed to an entity has to be exercised by individuals, and that authority means being able to control the disposition of the funds by communicating directly with the bank. If you can move money out of the garden centre's account, you generally have an FBAR reporting obligation for it, even though the money belongs to the company.
How does the freehold site show up on a US return?
The freehold is relieved under two different systems. In the UK, a company may claim the structures and buildings allowance on qualifying construction costs. For US purposes the company's earnings and profits are recomputed using US depreciation rules, so the figure on Form 5471 will not match the UK accounts or the CT600.
The structures and buildings allowance is a UK capital allowance that gives straight-line relief on the cost of constructing or renovating a non-residential building. GOV.UK sets out the rules at https://www.gov.uk/guidance/claiming-capital-allowances-for-structures-and-buildings, for Corporation Tax the rate is 3% a year from 1 April 2020 (2% before that), the construction contract must have been signed on or after 29 October 2018, and the allowance runs for 33 and one third years. Land does not qualify, nor do costs that qualify for plant and machinery allowances, planning fees or financing costs. The claimant needs a written allowance statement, and when the building is sold the allowances claimed are added to the disposal proceeds.
For a garden centre this produces a patchy picture. A new coffee shop extension or a rebuilt shop hall commissioned after October 2018 may carry the allowance; the original 1980s sales building does not; a glasshouse with heating and irrigation may have been treated partly as plant. On the US side none of the UK labels matter. The company's assets are depreciated for earnings and profits purposes under the US alternative depreciation system, which spreads buildings and land improvements over long recovery periods, and land is never depreciated under either system. In the returns we prepare, the freehold is often the single biggest source of difference between UK book profit and US earnings and profits, and it has to be rebuilt asset by asset from the fixed asset register.
Are concession rents and the cafe treated differently from plant sales?
They can be. Plant sales and cafe takings are ordinary active trading income. Rent or licence fees from concession traders are property income, and under the US controlled foreign corporation rules rents can count as passive income unless the company itself actively manages the letting. Each income line needs classifying before the Form 5471 is finished.
Concession arrangements vary a great deal. Some traders pay a fixed annual rent for a unit; some pay a percentage of their turnover through the garden centre's tills; some are effectively departments with the centre's own staff on the counter. A fixed rent from an outside aquatics business looks like property income. A turnover share where the centre runs the tills, the marketing and the car park looks much more like part of the retail trade. We read the agreements, not the ledger code.
The UK corporation tax rate the company pays also matters to the US analysis. GOV.UK at https://www.gov.uk/corporation-tax-rates currently gives a 25% main rate for profits above £250,000, a 19% small profits rate for profits of £50,000 or less, and marginal relief in between, with the thresholds reduced for short periods and associated companies. The US rules include a high-tax exception that can take highly taxed foreign income out of the passive and tested income calculations if an election is made. A garden centre company paying the main rate usually clears that test comfortably. One on the small profits rate sits much closer to the line, and once income is recomputed on US principles, with different depreciation, the effective rate can fall below it. That is a computation to run, not an assumption to make.
Does a January year-end and the Christmas peak cause US problems?
Often, yes. Many garden centres choose a January or February year-end so the books close after Christmas, when stock and staff are at their lowest. The US rules on foreign company tax years can require a US-controlled company to report on a different year, which means rebuilding figures to a cut-off around the busiest weeks of trading.
Section 898 of the Internal Revenue Code governs the tax year of certain US-owned foreign companies, and in many owner-managed cases it points the US computation towards the US shareholder's calendar year, with a limited election for a year ending one month earlier. Whether it applies to your company depends on the ownership facts, which we check on each file. Where it does apply, a UK set of accounts to 31 January cannot simply be lifted into Form 5471.
This is where garden centres differ from almost every other retailer we file for. At 31 December the shop floor may still hold unsold trees, lights, gift stock and grotto costs, while the cash from November and December trading sits in the bank and the VAT on it has not yet been paid over. A US-year cut-off has to capture stock at cost, accrued wages, the VAT liability and any deposits taken for spring orders. Most centres run monthly management accounts, so the data exists; it has simply never been cut at 31 December.
Should you use the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures or file late with a reasonable cause statement?
If you lived outside the US, your failure was non-willful and you have unfiled returns or unreported income, the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures are usually the right route because compliant filers face no penalties. If every Form 1040 was filed and only company information returns are missing, the delinquent international information return route may fit better.
The IRS sets out the foreign streamlined rules at https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/us-taxpayers-residing-outside-the-united-states. A US citizen meets the non-residency test if, in at least one of the three most recent years, they were physically outside the United States for at least 330 full days and did not have a US abode. The failure must have been non-willful, which the IRS describes as conduct due to negligence, inadvertence or mistake, or a good-faith misunderstanding of the law. The package is:
- Returns for the three most recent tax years whose due date has passed: original Forms 1040 where nothing was filed, or Forms 1040-X where a return was filed, together with the information returns such as Form 5471 and Form 8938.
- FBARs for the six most recent years whose due date has passed, filed electronically through FinCEN's BSA E-Filing System with Other selected as the late-filing reason and Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures entered in the explanation.
- Full payment of any tax and statutory interest due for the three years.
- An original signed Form 14653, the non-residency and non-willfulness certification, with copies attached to each tax return and information return but not to the FBARs.
- Streamlined Foreign Offshore written in red at the top of the first page of every return and information return, and the whole set posted on paper to the dedicated IRS address in Austin, since electronic submission is not accepted.
The same IRS page states that taxpayers who comply will not be subject to failure-to-file, failure-to-pay, accuracy-related, information return or FBAR penalties, although returns can still be examined and penalties already assessed for those years are not abated. It also notes that owners of specified foreign corporations may need to address the section 965 transition tax, which is relevant if your garden centre company had built up retained profits before 2018. The 5% miscellaneous offshore penalty applies only to the separate Streamlined Domestic Offshore Procedures, for people who fail the non-residency test.
The alternative is described at https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/delinquent-international-information-return-submission-procedures. It is open to people who are not under IRS examination or investigation and have not been contacted about the missing returns. You attach a reasonable cause statement, but the IRS says penalties may be assessed without considering it, in which case you answer the correspondence and resubmit the explanation. It suits an owner who filed Forms 1040 and reported all income but never attached a Form 5471.
One route no longer exists in the form many older guides describe. The IRS page for the Delinquent FBAR Submission Procedures was withdrawn around July 2026, so late FBARs on their own now go through BSA E-Filing with a reason for late filing, and FBARs that sit alongside missing returns go inside the streamlined package.
Which route fits your garden centre? A decision list
- If you have lived in the UK throughout, never filed Forms 1040 for recent years, and the lapse was non-willful, then use the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures.
- If you filed Forms 1040 and reported all of your salary and dividends but never attached Form 5471 or Form 8865, then consider the delinquent international information return route with a reasonable cause statement for each form.
- If your returns are complete and only FBARs are missing, then file the late FBARs through BSA E-Filing with a late-filing reason.
- If you moved to the UK recently and were not outside the US for 330 full days without a US abode in any of the last three years, then the domestic streamlined route and its 5% penalty may be the relevant option.
- If the IRS has already contacted you, or there are facts that look deliberate, then do not use either streamlined route until the facts have been reviewed in full.
What does a catch-up look like for a garden centre company?
The following is an illustration with invented figures, not a client case. A US citizen has lived in England since 2010 and owns all the shares in a garden centre company. The company owns a freehold site with a shop hall, two glasshouses, a cafe and three concession units. Its year-end is 31 January. Turnover is around £3.9 million and profit before tax around £340,000, so the company pays corporation tax at the main rate. The owner draws a salary of £50,000 and dividends of £110,000 a year and can sign on four company bank accounts plus two personal accounts. No US return has been filed since 2016.
Filing under the foreign streamlined procedures in November 2026, the three most recent tax years with a passed due date are 2023, 2024 and 2025, and the six FBAR years are 2020 to 2025. The package therefore contains three Forms 1040, each with Form 1116, Form 8938 and a Form 5471 for the company, six FBARs listing all six accounts, and one original Form 14653. For illustration only we assume an exchange rate of £1 = $1.27. Real returns use the rate appropriate to each year.
On those assumptions the salary is about $63,500 and the dividends about $139,700 a year. The UK income tax already paid on both is credited through Form 1116, and in this illustration the credit covers most or all of the US liability on that income. The cash cost of the catch-up is therefore small. The work is in the company: rebuilding three US years from accounts that end on 31 January, depreciating the shop hall, glasshouses and cafe fit-out on the US system, deciding whether the concession rents are active or passive, and testing whether the company's US-basis effective rate clears the high-tax threshold. Without the streamlined route, each missing Form 5471 could carry its own penalty and, while a required Form 5471 is outstanding, the period in which the IRS can assess the related return can stay open.
What records should a garden centre owner gather first?
Start with the documents that drive the company computations, because they take longest. Statutory accounts, monthly management accounts, the fixed asset register, concession agreements and bank statements matter more than your personal paperwork, which is usually easier to assemble from Self Assessment records and P60s.
- Statutory accounts and CT600s for every company year overlapping the US years being filed.
- Monthly management accounts or trial balances, so figures can be cut to 31 December if a calendar year is needed.
- The fixed asset register split between land, buildings, glasshouses and polytunnels, fit-out and equipment, with construction contract dates and any structures and buildings allowance statements.
- Every concession agreement, noting whether the trader pays a fixed rent, a turnover share or a licence fee, and who staffs the tills.
- Stock counts or stock system reports at the UK year-end and at 31 December, including Christmas stock.
- Share register and any shareholder agreements showing exact ownership percentages.
- Bank statements for every personal and company account you can sign on, with the highest balance in each calendar year.
- Self Assessment returns, HMRC statements, P60s and dividend vouchers for the UK tax credited on the US return.
- A travel log or passport records for the 330-day non-residency test.
What if the garden centre is a sole trade or a partnership?
A sole trader reports the garden centre's profit on Schedule C and faces US self-employment tax unless covered by UK National Insurance under the US-UK social security agreement. A partnership or LLP usually means Form 8865 each year.
For a sole trader, the US-UK social security agreement generally allocates a self-employed person living in the UK to the UK system, but the exemption from US self-employment tax is not automatic. The owner needs a certificate of coverage from the UK side, requested through HMRC, and keeps it with the US return. In a catch-up we check that a certificate covers every year being filed. The trading profit itself is computed on US rules, so the same freehold and stock questions arise, just without a Form 5471.
Partnerships are common where a garden centre has been run by a couple or by siblings. Form 8865 needs the partnership's income, balance sheet and each partner's share. A UK LLP raises a further question about how the US classifies the entity, which turns on its default classification and any elections made, so we confirm that before preparing the first year. Your share of profit lands directly on your own return.
How do UK taxes carry across without double taxation?
UK income tax you pay personally on salary, dividends or sole-trade profit can generally be credited against US tax on the same income through Form 1116. Corporation tax paid by your garden centre company is different: as an individual shareholder you cannot normally credit it directly, which is why the company-level US rules matter.
In most of the returns we prepare for UK business owners, personal UK tax rates are high enough that the foreign tax credit removes most of the US tax on salary and dividends. The exposure, where there is any, tends to come from income the US taxes on a different basis or at a different time than the UK, for instance company income picked up under the controlled foreign corporation rules before any dividend is paid. An individual can sometimes elect under section 962 to be taxed as if a corporation on that income, which brings a credit for the company's UK tax into play.
What mistakes do we see in garden centre catch-up filings?
- Leaving the company's bank accounts off the FBAR because the money belongs to the business.
- Copying UK accounting profit straight into Form 5471 without US depreciation or year-end adjustments.
- Coding all concession income as sales, or all of it as rent, without reading the agreements.
- Filing an original Form 1040 for a year where a return was already filed, instead of Form 1040-X.
- Sending a photocopy of Form 14653 rather than the original signed certification, or forgetting the red streamlined marking.
- Treating the withdrawn Delinquent FBAR Submission Procedures page as a live route.
What happens after the catch-up is filed?
Once the package is posted, the IRS processes the returns in the ordinary way. Keep a full copy of every form, the proof of posting and the BSA E-Filing confirmations for the FBARs, because that file is your evidence of what was submitted and when. Keep the working papers behind each Form 5471 too.
From then on the garden centre needs an annual US cycle sitting next to the UK one. That means a calendar-year cut-off taken from the management accounts each January, the fixed asset register maintained on both UK and US bases, concession agreements reviewed when they renew, and bank maximum balances captured each year for the FBAR. If the business or the freehold is later sold, the US history you have rebuilt becomes the starting point for that computation.
Related reading and tools
- US Tax Services & IRS Compliance
- UK Tax Services
- IRS Streamlined Filing
- UK Income Tax Calculator
- US Federal Income Tax Calculator
Every situation is different. Book a cross-border tax consultation to discuss how these rules apply to you.
Authoritative sources
IRS — Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures
FinCEN — Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR)
GOV.UK — Tax on foreign income
IRS — Foreign Earned Income Exclusion



