US Tax Return Preparation for Expats Taking Italy's Flat Tax
By US-UK Tax Advisors cross-border tax team · Last updated OCT 28, 2026

Moving from London to Italy on the new-resident flat tax? Your US return still taxes worldwide income, and the Italian lump sum may give no US credit at all.
Key Takeaways
- Covers cross-border tax for US-UK cross-border taxpayers
- Applies to US persons with UK ties and UK residents with US income
- Highlights the filing, reporting and tax-treaty points to check
- Get personalised advice before acting on your own facts
US tax return preparation for expats who elect Italy's flat tax is not simplified by the election: a US citizen still files a full Form 1040 reporting worldwide income, and the Italian lump sum may give little or no US foreign tax credit. That is the short answer. The Italian regime fixes what you pay Italy on foreign income; it does nothing to what you owe Washington. For a London-based American leaving after the end of the remittance basis, the move creates three filing systems in one year.
In the returns we prepare, the Italian election is usually sound on the Italian side. The difficulty is that US credit rules were written for taxes computed on income, and a fixed annual charge does not fit them.
What is Italy's flat tax for new residents?
Italy's flat tax for new residents is an optional regime under article 24-bis of the Italian consolidated income tax code (TUIR) that lets an individual who moves tax residence to Italy pay a fixed annual substitute tax on foreign-source income instead of ordinary Italian income tax on that income. The Italian Revenue Agency's own reference page at https://www.agenziaentrate.gov.it/portale/schede/agevolazioni/opzione-per-i-neo-residenti/normativa-e-prassi-regi-opz-neo-residenti lists the legal basis: article 24-bis of the TUIR, in force since 1 January 2017, the implementing measure of 8 March 2017, and later amendments made by article 2 of Decree-Law 113/2024 and by article 1, paragraphs 25 and 26, of the 2026 Budget Law (Law 199/2025).
The features that matter for a US filer can be stated in outline. The charge is a fixed amount per tax year, set by statute and not calculated on how much foreign income you actually have. It replaces Italian income tax on income that Italy regards as foreign-source; income Italy regards as Italian-source stays under ordinary Italian rules. The option can be extended to family members for a further fixed amount each, it can be revoked, and it ends in any event after fifteen years. It is available only to someone who has not been Italian tax resident for most of the preceding decade (the Agency's guidance refers to nine of the ten prior tax periods), and the charge is paid in a single instalment by the normal balance due date using a dedicated payment code.
We deliberately do not quote the annual figure here. The amount has been raised since the regime started, and the official Agency page we reviewed lists the amending laws without restating the current figures. Before modelling anything, we take the amount that applies to the specific election year from the Italian legislation itself, because new arrivals and earlier electors may be on different figures.
Do US citizens in Italy still file a US tax return?
Yes. The United States taxes its citizens on worldwide income wherever they live, and an Italian election changes nothing about that. A US citizen resident in Italy files Form 1040 every year, reports every dollar of income from every country, and claims relief for foreign tax only through the mechanisms the Internal Revenue Code allows: the foreign earned income exclusion for qualifying earned income, the foreign tax credit, and treaty provisions where they apply.
The US-Italy income tax convention does not rescue the position. The convention text published by the IRS at https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-trty/italy.pdf contains a saving clause in paragraph 2 of Article 1: each country may tax its citizens by reason of citizenship as if there were no convention, subject to a short list of preserved benefits that includes the relief from double taxation article. The IRS treaty index at https://www.irs.gov/businesses/international-businesses/italy-tax-treaty-documents lists both that 1984 convention and a later 1999 convention with its technical explanation, and in the returns we prepare we work from the convention text in force for the year being filed. Either way, treaty residence in Italy does not switch off US citizenship-based taxation.
Is the Italian lump-sum tax a creditable foreign income tax for the US?
This is the central question in US tax return preparation for expats who take the Italian election, and it does not have a clean answer. Section 901 of the Internal Revenue Code allows a credit for foreign income taxes, and section 903 extends that to taxes paid in lieu of an income tax. The regulations set the tests, and a fixed amount that is not computed on income has difficulty with most of them.
Under the regulations at https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.901-2, a foreign levy is a foreign income tax only if it is a tax and is either a net income tax or a tax in lieu of an income tax. A net income tax must satisfy a net gain requirement made up of realization, gross receipts, cost recovery and attribution tests. A fixed annual sum owed whether foreign income is large, small or nil is not imposed on realized gross receipts less costs, so on the face of the regulation it is hard to see it passing as a net income tax. Each levy is tested separately, so Italian ordinary tax on Italian-source income is not tainted by the lump sum.
The in lieu of route at https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.903-1 is the more interesting argument. The regulation says the base of an in lieu of tax need not be net gain and gives gross income, gross receipts or units produced as examples. But the tax must still meet a substitution requirement: the country must have a generally imposed net income tax, that net income tax must not also reach the excluded income, there must be proof that the country made a cognizant and deliberate choice to impose the tested tax instead of its income tax, and the income tax, had it applied, would have met the attribution rules. A tax paid in addition to an income tax rather than in its place does not qualify.
Arguments can be built on both sides. In favour: the Italian charge is expressly a substitute for Italian personal income tax on the foreign income, and the statutory design looks like a deliberate choice to replace the ordinary tax. Against: the charge is not measured by any income at all, the attribution test asks whether Italy's ordinary tax would have reached that income on a basis the US accepts, and the amount bears no relation to the income it is said to replace. We have not found published IRS guidance that resolves the point for this regime, and we treat it as uncertain.
In practice we do not claim the credit by default; where a client wants to, we document the substitution analysis and model the return both ways.
Can the US-Italy treaty make the lump sum creditable?
This is the first gap angle most guides miss. The regulations allow a levy to be treated as a foreign income tax where an income tax treaty requires it; the paragraph structure in https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.901-2 includes a specific rule for treaty-modified levies. So the question becomes whether the US-Italy convention reaches the Italian substitute tax.
In the 1984 convention text published by the IRS, Article 2 lists the Italian taxes covered (the individual income tax, the corporate income tax and the then-local income tax) and extends the convention to identical or substantially similar taxes imposed after signature in addition to, or in place of, the existing taxes. Article 23, the double taxation relief article, then says that for the US credit the covered Italian taxes are to be considered income taxes. If the Italian substitute tax were a substantially similar tax imposed in place of the individual income tax, the treaty could carry it into the US credit.
The obstacle is the words substantially similar. A charge that is fixed, not computed on income and payable regardless of results is structurally very different from a progressive tax on net income. We are not aware of a competent authority statement or IRS position confirming that the Italian substitute tax is covered. Treaty-based return positions also carry their own disclosure obligation on Form 8833 in many cases. Our working view is that the treaty argument exists, is not settled, and should be presented on the return only with full documentation and a clear decision by the client on disclosure.
Why does US-source income make the credit problem worse?
This is the second gap. Italy's regime covers income Italy treats as foreign-source. For an American investor, a large share of that foreign income is often US-source: dividends from US companies, interest from US issuers, gains on US securities. The US foreign tax credit limitation only allows credit against US tax on foreign-source income. Even a fully creditable foreign tax on US-source income would ordinarily produce no usable credit because there is no foreign-source income in that category to absorb it.
The 1984 convention addresses this for ordinary Italian taxes. Article 23 contains a resourcing rule under which, for an individual resident in Italy, income the US taxes only by reason of citizenship is deemed to arise in Italy to the extent necessary to avoid double taxation, but never so as to reduce US tax below what a non-citizen would pay, and the resourcing applies only for credits for the Italian taxes covered by the convention. That rule is useful where Italy taxes US-source income under its ordinary system. If the substitute tax is not a covered tax, the resourcing rule does not help, and an American with mainly US-source investment income may find that the lump sum is both of doubtful creditability and, even if creditable, largely unusable.
A further mechanical issue sits underneath. A single fixed amount must be allocated across the income it relates to and across US limitation categories, mainly passive. No Italian assessment apportions it, so the allocation has to be built and supported on the US side.
Should an American still take the Italian flat tax?
Sometimes. The election can still make sense for a US citizen in specific circumstances, and it is plainly wrong in others. The factors we look at when preparing projections are:
- How much foreign income Italy would otherwise tax under its ordinary progressive rules, and at what Italian rate, compared with the fixed charge for the election year.
- How much of that foreign income is US-source, because ordinary Italian tax on US-source income may be credited through treaty resourcing while the substitute tax may not.
- Whether the US-source portion is already taxed at favourable US rates, such as qualified dividends and long-term gains, which narrows the gap between US and Italian burdens.
- Whether family members would be added to the election, since each extension carries its own fixed amount and the US creditability question repeats for each US citizen spouse.
- Non-US foreign income such as UK, European or Asian investment income, where Italy's ordinary tax could otherwise generate creditable foreign tax against US tax on that same income.
In the files we see, the election works best for an American with large non-US, non-Italian income and worst for one whose wealth sits mostly in US-listed securities, which is the typical London American profile.
What happens on the UK side in the year you leave London?
Leaving the UK is a separate compliance event with its own return. Residence for a UK tax year is decided under the statutory residence test, and in a year where you are UK resident and leave part-way through, split-year treatment may divide the year into a UK part and an overseas part. HMRC's guidance at https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/rdr3-statutory-residence-test-srt/guidance-note-for-statutory-residence-test-srt-rdr3 explains that on departure you must consider each of the departure cases, that every condition in a case must be met for it to apply, and that priority rules decide the split date where more than one case fits. The detailed conditions for the departure cases, including ceasing to have a UK home, are set out in HMRC's residence manual.
Split-year treatment is valuable but not automatic. In the returns we prepare, the most common failure is a London flat kept available after the move, which defeats the case the client assumed would apply.
Can UK temporary non-residence rules catch gains after the move?
Yes, and this is the UK risk that interacts directly with an Italian election. The same HMRC guidance explains that temporary non-residence rules apply where a period of sole UK residence is followed by non-residence lasting five years or less, and the individual had sole UK residence in at least four of the seven tax years before the year of departure. Most long-term London residents meet that second test easily.
If you return to the UK within that window, certain income and gains received or realized while abroad can be taxed in the year of return. HMRC's non-exhaustive list includes capital gains, offshore income gains, distributions from closely controlled companies, chargeable event gains and, for former remittance basis users, foreign income remitted to the UK during the period of absence. That last item matters for the reader of this article: former remittance basis users who bring pre-departure foreign income or gains into the UK during a short Italian stay can find that the remittance is taxed when they come back.
The US return reports the same gains in the year they are realized regardless. So a short Italian stay followed by a return to London can produce a US charge, an Italian fixed charge that may not be creditable, and a later UK charge on return, with timing mismatches between all three. If a return to the UK within five years is a realistic possibility, we model it before any significant disposal is made from Italy.
How is the US return prepared in the year of the move?
The year of the move is the most complex US return the client will file in the cycle. The US tax year is the calendar year, the UK year runs to 5 April, and the Italian residence start date follows Italian rules, so the return must reconcile three different period definitions. The items we work through on every relocation file:
- Foreign earned income exclusion versus foreign tax credit: the exclusion covers only earned income and only for a period in which a tax home abroad and either bona fide residence or physical presence abroad is established. Investment income, which dominates most high-net-worth returns, is never excluded, so the credit is usually the main relief.
- Allocation of UK tax paid in the split year: UK income tax and capital gains tax on the UK part of the year remain creditable foreign taxes, subject to the normal limitation and category rules, and UK payments-on-account timing must be matched to the correct US year.
- Italian ordinary tax on Italian-source income: tax on Italian-source items such as Italian employment income, Italian rents or Italian-source investment income is analysed separately from the lump sum and is generally the most straightforward credit in the file.
- Information returns for new and closing accounts, foreign funds and any Italian or UK companies, covered in the next sections.
Do new Italian accounts need an FBAR and Form 8938?
Almost certainly. The IRS comparison of the two regimes at https://www.irs.gov/businesses/comparison-of-form-8938-and-fbar-requirements confirms that an FBAR (FinCEN Form 114) is required when the aggregate value of foreign financial accounts exceeds $10,000 at any time in the calendar year, and that it is filed electronically through FinCEN's BSA E-Filing System, not with the tax return. It is due on April 15 with an automatic extension to October 15. A London American moving to Italy will usually report UK accounts closed during the year and Italian accounts opened during the year on the same FBAR, using the maximum value of each account.
Form 8938 is filed with the income tax return. For a taxpayer living abroad, the same IRS page sets the reporting thresholds at more than $200,000 at year end or more than $300,000 at any time for an unmarried filer or a married person filing separately, and more than $400,000 at year end or more than $600,000 at any time for a married couple filing jointly. Penalties for failing to file Form 8938 start at $10,000 and can increase after an IRS notice, while FBAR civil penalties are adjusted annually for inflation.
If earlier years were missed, a late FBAR is filed through the BSA E-Filing System with a statement of the reason for late filing, or the missing years are brought into compliance through the Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures where the eligibility conditions are met. Under the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures, for non-willful taxpayers who meet the non-residency requirement, there is no penalty.
Are Italian investment funds PFICs for a US taxpayer?
Generally yes. Italian and other European pooled investment funds, including the funds commonly bundled into private banking mandates and insurance-wrapped investment products, are usually passive foreign investment companies for US purposes because their income and assets are overwhelmingly passive. A PFIC held without a qualified electing fund or mark-to-market election is taxed under the excess distribution regime, which can turn ordinary market gains into tax at the highest ordinary rate plus an interest charge, and each PFIC generally needs its own Form 8621.
New Italian portfolios are often built from European-domiciled funds, and under the election Italy is largely indifferent to how foreign investment returns are taxed. The US is not. Before an Italian portfolio is built, we ask whether the funds provide the annual statements needed for a qualified electing fund election, or whether direct holdings are possible. Unwinding a PFIC portfolio later is expensive.
Worked scenario: a London American moving to Milan
The following figures are an illustration only. They are rounded, they are not a computation of anyone's liability, and the exchange rate and Italian charge are assumptions.
Assume Claire is a single US citizen who has lived in London for twelve years and used the remittance basis in earlier years. She ceases to have a UK home and moves to Milan, becoming Italian resident from the start of an Italian tax year, and elects the substitute tax regime. In her first full Italian year she has no earned income. Her income is $2,000,000 of US-source qualified dividends and long-term gains from a US brokerage account and $800,000 of non-US foreign-source passive income from UK and European holdings, for $2,800,000 in total.
For illustration, assume her US federal income tax on that income, including the net investment income tax, comes to about $640,000, and assume an Italian substitute charge equivalent to $330,000 (an illustrative charge of EUR 300,000 at an assumed rate of 1.10 dollars per euro; the actual amount must be taken from the Italian legislation for her election year).
Position A, the lump sum is not creditable: Claire pays roughly $640,000 to the US and $330,000 to Italy, a combined $970,000, or about 35% of her income. Position B, the lump sum is creditable but only against US tax on foreign-source income: her foreign-source share is $800,000 of $2,800,000, so the passive category limitation is roughly 29% of the regular US tax on that income. Illustratively, if about $150,000 of US tax relates to that foreign-source income, she can use up to about $150,000 of credit, leaving about $180,000 of the charge unused in that year and subject to the carryover rules. The combined bill is still around $820,000.
Position C, Claire does not elect the regime and is taxed in Italy under ordinary rules: Italy would tax her worldwide income at progressive rates, and her US-source income could then benefit from treaty resourcing for the covered Italian tax. Whether C beats A or B depends on the Italian ordinary burden on her income mix. The decision turns on the US credit position, which most relocation projections never model.
In the same cycle Claire also files a UK departure-year return, an FBAR covering closed UK and new Italian accounts, Form 8938 and Form 8621 for any non-US funds. The US return is best finalised only once the Italian election and payment are confirmed, using an extension rather than a later amendment.
Key points for US tax return preparation for expats moving to Italy
The full US return stays in place whatever Italy offers. The fixed Italian charge is of uncertain US creditability, the treaty route is unsettled, and US-source portfolio income limits any credit even if allowed. The UK exit year needs its own split-year analysis, and new Italian accounts and funds bring FBAR, Form 8938 and PFIC reporting. Model the US position before the Italian election is made, not after.
Related reading and tools
- US Tax Services & IRS Compliance
- UK Tax Services
- IRS Streamlined Filing
- UK Income Tax Calculator
- US Federal Income Tax Calculator
Every situation is different. Book a cross-border tax consultation to discuss how these rules apply to you.
Authoritative sources
IRS — Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures
FinCEN — Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR)
GOV.UK — Tax on foreign income
IRS — Foreign Earned Income Exclusion



